The Wall Street Journal

May 27, 2004

PERSONAL TECHNOLOGY
By WALTER S. MOSSBERG


DOW JONES REPRINTS
This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers, use the Order Reprints tool at the bottom of any article or visit:
www.djreprints.com.

• See a sample reprint in PDF format.
• Order a reprint of this article now.




 
MOSSBERG'S MAILBOX
Walter S. Mossberg answers readers' questions2 about computers and technology.

 

 
ABOUT WALT MOSSBERG
Walt Mossberg is the author and creator of the weekly Personal Technology column in The Wall Street Journal, which has appeared every Thursday since 1991. The goal of the column is "to take the consumer's side in the struggle to master the machine, to deliver a weekly dose of useful information in plain English, but in a way that never condescends to our readers just because they can't tell one chip from another."

 
Mr. Mossberg also writes the Mossberg Solution, which premiered April 9, 2002, and Mossberg's Mailbox. He is also a contributing editor of Smart Money, the Journal's monthly magazine, where he writes the Mossberg Report column. On television, Mr. Mossberg appears frequently as a technology commentator for the CNBC network.

 
Mr. Mossberg has been a reporter and editor at the Journal since 1970. He is based in the Journal's Washington, D.C., office, where he spent 18 years covering national and international affairs before turning his attention to technology.

 

This Product Makes
Switching ISPs Easy,
Despite Annoyances
May 27, 2004; Page B1

Admit it. You hate your Internet service provider. You're dying to switch to a competitor with faster access or lower prices. But you stay with your old ISP because you can't figure out how to move over your address book, calendar entries and Web favorites list -- at least without hours of tedious work. And you dread notifying all your regular contacts that you have a new e-mail address.

If this is you, my friend, cheer up. Hope has arrived, in the form of a small, private New York City company called Esaya Inc. The people at Esaya have developed a product called TrueSwitch that they claim can automate this whole process for you, and take the pain out of switching ISPs.

I decided to test that claim and use TrueSwitch to transfer my key information from a couple of ISPs to a couple of others. I found that it works as advertised, and, except for a few annoyances, it's clean and simple.

TrueSwitch was invented as a service Esaya sold to ISPs seeking to woo members away from rivals. I first encountered it as a free tool offered by Microsoft's MSN service to people who switched from Time Warner's America Online service. You can still get TrueSwitch this way from MSN and a few other ISPs.

But now, anyone can download and use TrueSwitch to move personal data from almost any major ISP to any other. The program costs $20, but if it detects you are switching to one of the ISPs with which Esaya has deals, it's free. The software is available at www.trueswitch.com.

TrueSwitch is especially popular with people leaving AOL. That's partly because AOL is the largest dial-up ISP, and it has been bleeding members to broadband services offered by cable and phone companies. But it's also because, unlike many smaller ISPs, AOL has deliberately made it hard to switch by using proprietary software and formats from which it's difficult to extract data like e-mail and addresses.

To be fair, AOL recently began loosening this tight grip on your data. It now offers a free utility that can synchronize your address book and calendar with either a PDA or with Windows programs like Outlook, Outlook Express and the Palm Desktop. You can download this tool at AOL keyword: "Sync." But this approach doesn't handle e-mail or Web favorites, and it doesn't notify your contacts you have a new e-mail address.

TrueSwitch has four functions. First, and most importantly, it copies your data from your old account to the new one. This includes stored e-mail messages, address-book entries, and, where relevant, calendar entries and Web favorites, or bookmarks. If you are using software like Outlook or Outlook Express to manage the new account, most of these items are transferred there. Favorites wind up in Internet Explorer.

If the data are stored on the ISP's servers, as opposed to your own PC, it can take up to 24 hours to accomplish. The e-mail, addresses and other data aren't deleted from your old software, merely copied.

Secondly, TrueSwitch will send an e-mail to everyone in your address book, notifying them of your change of e-mail address. You can personalize this message. Third, it will forward e-mail from your old account to your new one for up to 30 days. Finally, it will provide instructions on how to cancel your old ISP account.

The software itself downloads quickly and takes the form of a simple, step-by-step "wizard." It even detects all your accounts automatically to make it easy to choose the old and new accounts for switching.

TrueSwitch can be run in two modes. You can use the "Express Switching" mode to have the software perform all the functions in a standard manner. But I recommend the "Custom Switching" mode, which allows you to pick and choose among parts of the process. For instance, you could fetch your data but decide not to send the change-of-address notices or to forward e-mail. You can also specify which kinds of data to import, which people to notify and so forth.

In my tests, I successfully transferred my e-mails, address book and favorites from AOL to a Comcast cable modem account I manage via Outlook Express. I also successfully moved my data from a Web-based Hotmail account to an Outlook Express-based e-mail account provided by a small regional ISP. In both cases, everything worked fine, although I didn't have any calendar entries to test and I didn't send change-of-address notices.

I did run into a few annoyances. When you download the software, it automatically installs itself and starts running, whether you're ready for it or not. Also, TrueSwitch doesn't transfer old e-mail from AOL, only mail in the in box.

Finally, TrueSwitch installs one of those irritating modules that run constantly in the tray at the lower right corner of the Windows screen. This is ostensibly to be able to send you messages about the progress of your account switch. But I think it's at least partly to try to tempt you to buy other Esaya products, like a pop-up blocker and a spyware detector. There's even a "system checkup" function that purportedly finds problems and then recommends the company's other products as solutions.

All in all, though, TrueSwitch is a good product that solves a real problem.

Write to Walter S. Mossberg at mossberg@wsj.com1

URL for this article:
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB108561200733322356,00.html

Hyperlinks in this Article:
(1) mailto:mossberg@wsj.com
(2) http://online.wsj.com/articles/mossberg_mailbox
Copyright 2004 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved
This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit www.djreprints.com.